|
What Exactly Is Consensus?
Consensus is a decision making process which equalizes power over
a group of people. Instead of simply voting for an item, and having
the majority of the group get their way, the group has to sit down
and get a solution to a problem that EVERYONE is ok with. People take
different ideas and we see how we feel about them. The solution that
the group thinks is the most positive gets chosen, unless a member
of the group finds the solution totally unacceptable. Consensus is
based o comporomise, and the ability to find common ground.
Why Would We Want to
Use Consensus?
Consensus is a system that promotes participation because each person
has the power to make changes in the system, and to prevent changes
that they find unacceptable. People are often inactive because they
feel that they have no power in the system and their voice won't be
listened to. (Isn't that why so few people vote in most industrial
democracies?). Imagine if corporations has to have consensus from
a community to build a plastic factory near them, or an incinerator.
Shouldn't this be what happens regularly?
Since consensus would give
everyone power to have their voice be heard, it would force people
to listen to each other, and answer their concerns instead of moving
past them.
But's What's Wrong with
a Majority Rule System?
The majority rule system is set up to have a winner and a loser. This
promotes conflict, and lends itself to steamrolling an idea over a
minority that dissents with the majority opintion. People in a majority
rule system don't need to listen to the dissenting minority, or take
their opinion seriously because they can simply outvote them. Majority
rule systems say that the majority is infallible and they have nothing
to learn from the minority. There is no moral system at work with
a majority rule system, and there is nothing to say that the majority
of people will come up with a morally acceptable system. (I mean,
didn't the majority of colonial Americans support the ``right'' to
hold slaves?).
But We Wouldn't Be Able
to Accomplish Anything!
Well, this isn't exactly true. Using consensus based decisions the
Iroquis nation managed their lands and people very effectively. More
recently, the Zapatista network in southern Mexico has been using
consensus decision making with everyone 16 and over participating.
Any proposal by the Mexican Gov't has been endlessly discussed by
each small village in the Zapatista network until everyone agrees.
The decision to wage war, and then continue after the Mexican Gov't
made some initial concessions was done consensually with a 98.2% approval.
Consensus has also been
used at 300 person anti-nuclear protests, and during all sorts of
activities. It is an all-inclusive form of decision making that everyone
can walk away from comfortable and satisfied with the outcome.
Be Honest, What Are
the Bad Things About Consensus?
Since it is a lengthier process to hash out ideas until all objections
are resolved, your group meetings might be a bit longer and some proposals
might regularly take more than a week to decide. Also, since some
proposals may be just shot down without hope of compromise, consensus
sometimes favors the status quo.
See also: What
is consensus & How to build consensus
Note:
Can't remeber where I found this document but I know the authors won't
mind. It's Amazing How Much You Can Do When You Don't Care Who Gets
the Credit!
|